14 December 2010

Total War: Romanticism and the Rise of the Nation-State

Most of what is said about the nation-state is untrue, it is a product of romantic myth was designed to justify territorial demands during the time of war. It was put about in works of fiction and supported by popular culture and finally, by the state directed educational systems.

The major 'nations' of Europe are highly artificial and mythological. Britain is an 18th/19th Century political convenience and is a state made of at least four separate nations; each nation is also, to some extent fixitious.

In the Roman Empire and Middle Ages, people regarded themselves as being part of a nation.- The nation-state is modern and we don't know how long it will last .
In the Middle Ages sovereignty was divided, such as the Church is in secular matters. Europe was totally divided.
  • Pluralism- the opposite if totalitarianism
  • The State- a monopoloy of legitimate violence.

Thomas Hobbes

  • His theory of power is the 'artificial man'
  • He believed that the State of Nature was living in fear.
  • His solution was to alienate our rights to a supreme sovereignty in order to live in peace.
  • He says that the emerging state is already vast and artificial.
  • Hebbesian State is explicitly a war machine for subjects and rival states who resist.
  • In his system the greatest good arises when the whim of the personified state is automatically low- it does not matter if it's cruel or irrational.

The French Revolution

  • All forms of traditional feudal links to the state were swept away.
  • The French Revolution shows how the 'artificial man' will always remain; it is immortal and keeps reasserting itself.

Rousseau

  • He believed in the Social Contract and the rights of man.
  • He stated that the Social Contract was only designed for small states, for example, France. However, it was not suitable for bigger states such as, China.

Hegel

  • 'The state is God on Earth'
  • He believed that the State/ Nation was not natural

Hume

  • 'Authority is based on nothing but opinion'

Social division was all about survival of the fittest.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Tweet